Prior art
Encyclopedia : P : PR : PRI : Prior art
| Patentability |
|---|
|
| 1 Under European patent law, inventorship |
| ''is not relevant to patentability. |
| [http://encycl.opentopia.com/ edit box] |
In most patent laws, prior art is expected to provide a description sufficient to inform the average worker in the field (or the person skilled in the art), published in fixed form and made available in public libraries. Again, in most patent laws, prior art does not include unpublished work or mere conversations (though according to the European Patent Convention, oral disclosures also form prior art — see ). It is disputed whether traditional knowledge (e.g. of medical properties of a certain plant) constitutes prior art.
The term "prior art" is mainly used in the patent field. Patents disclose to society how an invention is practiced, in return for the right (during a limited term) to exclude others from manufacturing, selling, offering for sale or using the patented invention without the patentee's permission. Patent offices deal with prior art searches in the context of the patent granting procedure. To assess the validity of a patent application, patent offices explore the prior art that was disclosed before the invention occurred (in the United States and all first-to-invent patent systems) or before the filing date (in Europe and all first-to-file patent systems).
First-to-invent systems
The invention date can be legally bounded by descriptive documents signed by witnesses who understand the invention and can testify about what the inventor knew as of that date. The latest possible bound for the invention date is the patent application date. The United States uses a first-to-invent system.
First-to-file systems
Every country other than the United States uses a First-to-file system. This means that, regardless of who the first inventor was, the person who files a patent application first is the one who can be granted a patent for the invention. The First-to-invent versus First-to-file rule is one of the major dichotomies between U.S. patent law and the patents laws of many other nations. As of this writing (2004), harmonization efforts are underway with the goal being to unify the patent laws of various nations so that inventors have the same rights regardless of in which country a patent is granted.
Other considerations
Although patents normally go to the first inventor under a first-to-file system, an inventor who keeps the information secret or just does not publish generally loses the right to the patent and also does not establish prior art. Without prior art, a later inventor can get a valid patent on the same invention and then apply it against earlier inventor(s). All this is easily prevented simply by recognizing the invention and applying for a patent, or by publishing details of how to practice the invention, thus creating prior art.Prior art searching and novelty searches
Prior art searches or novelty searches are often conducted before filing a patent application or after filing to find one or more publications that predate the filing date of an issued patent or pending patent application. A prior art search helps an inventor determine if the invention is novel before committing the resources necessary to obtain a patent. This type of search is called a novelty search. Prior art searches may also be used to invalidate existing patents (these searches are called "validity searches" or "invalidity searches") by showing that the patent office erred in the issuance of a patent because the patent holder is not the first inventor.
Prior art searches are also useful to determine what a patent or patent application is really worth, before acquiring it or taking a license. If a publication predates the filing date of a patent application and discloses one or more features of an invention, then that publication is "material to the patentability of the claimed invention", and is considered to be prior art.
In the United States, inventors and their patent agents or attorneys are required by law to submit any prior art they are aware of to the United States Patent and Trademark Office so that the patent examiner can take the prior art into account when examining the patent application.
If prior art is discovered after a patent issues, it can be used to invalidate the patent. This can be done by a reexamination proceeding in the U.S., or an opposition proceeding in Europe or Japan.
Another type of patent search similar to a prior art search is a clearance search. A clearance search is done in order to see if a given product or process violates someone else's existing patent. If so, then a validity search may be done to try and find prior art that would invalidate the patent.
Relevant art
The United States Patent and Trademark Office (USPTO) refers to searching highly "relevant art" areas. United States Patent and Trademark Office web site, [http://www.uspto.gov/web/patents/searchtemplates/classd01-all.htm], retrieved on June 26, 2006 Relevant art includes current art whether prior or not.http://www.wipo.int/meetings/2006/scp_of_ge_06/en/presentations/scp_of_ge_06_roberts.pdf SUFFICIENCY OF DISCLOSURE (ENABLING DISCLOSURE, DISCLOSURE OF PRIOR ART, BEST MODE) Tim Roberts, Council Member, The Chartered Institute of Patent Agents, London Patent attorneys recommend using the term revelant art for material that is not obviously in the public domain. Relevant art is preferred over prior art as not admitting that the material is "prior" when the priority of one or more patents has not been litigated.References
See also
- esp@cenet - European Patent Office public prior art database.
- Micropatent
- Patent classification
- Patent watch
- Peanut butter and jelly sandwich: a patent with prior art disputes
- Priority right
- Defensive publication
Further reading
- Arnoud Engelfriet, [When is something prior art against a patent?], iusmentis.com web site, October 1, 2005, retrieved on June 3, 2006
- Walter J. Blenko, [Considering What Constitutes Prior Art in the United States], JOM, 43 (6) (1991), p. 45
- Dave Winer, [Prior art as a design method], Scripting News, June 18, 2003
External links
- [FreePatentsOnline.com] - Free prior art searching (US patents, US applications, and EP patents), notification service, and RSS feeds of new patents
- [USPTO.gov] - Free access to US patents.
- [IP.com Prior Art Database]
- [Open Source as Prior Art] - including [HowTo search for Prior Art in the Internet] and [Example Prior Art search] for a real Patent
- [WIPO search engine for international PCT patent applications]
- [Links to national patent offices including US, Japan, UK etc.]
- [USPTO search engine for patent and patent application file histories. Displays reasons why patents are issued.]
- [Free biomedical patent search for genes and species].
- [PATLIB - European Patent Library network]
From Wikipedia, the Free Encyclopedia. Original article here. Support Wikipedia by contributing or donating.
All text is available under the terms of the GNU Free Documentation License See Wikipedia Copyrights for details.