Yilmaz theory of gravitation
Encyclopedia : Y : YI : YIL : Yilmaz theory of gravitation
The Yilmaz theory of gravitation is an attempt by Huseyin Yilmaz and a handful of coworkers to formulate a classical field theory of gravitation which closely mimics general relativity in weak-field conditions, but in which event horizons cannot appear.
(Orthographic caveat: in Turkish, Yilmaz's name is properly written Hüseyin Yılmaz; we will avoid this spelling because English-speaking readers are likely to misread the ı as i, which could cause technical difficulties. The spelling we use is the one Yilmaz adopts in the arXiv.)
Yilmaz's work has been sharply criticized on various grounds, including the claims that
- his proposed field equation is ill-defined,
- the two desiderata above are incompatible (event horizons can occur in weak field situations according to gtr, in the case of a supermassive black hole).
It is well known that naive attempts to quantize general relativity along the same lines which lead from Maxwell's classical field theory of electromagnetism to quantum electrodynamics fail, and that it has proven very difficult to construct a theory of quantum gravity which goes over to general relativity in an appropriate limit. Yilmaz has claimed that, in contrast, his theory is in some sense 'compatible with quantum mechanics'. He even suggests that it might be an alternative to superstring theory. These claims have apparently been given no credence by physicists other than Yilmaz and a handful of his coworkers.
Yilmaz has offered several descriptions of the alleged field equation for his 'theory', which his critics feel are neither entirely consistent with each other nor well-defined. To understand one of the most basic criticisms of Yilmaz's work, one needs to be familiar with
- the statement of the Einstein field equation,
- the distinction between coordinate dependent and coordinate independent quantities,
- well known facts concerning integration in curved spacetimes,
- well known facts concerning gravitational energy-momentum pseudotensors in general relativity.
Yilmaz has apparently failed to produce a convincing proposal for an observational or experimental test of his theory, and it would appear that no astronomers have contemplated any attempts to test his ideas. On the other hand, astronomers are very interested indeed in testing theoretically solid competitors of general relativity; see .
See also
- List of fringe physics theories
External link
- one page in the website [Relativity on the World Wide Web] lists some apparent misstatements by Yilmaz concerning gtr, similar to those discussed by Fackerell.
References
- [eprint version] In this paper Misner (an internationally recognized expert on gtr) argues that Yilmaz's field equation is ill-defined.
- C. O. Alley; P. K. Aschan; and H. Yilmaz, [Refutation of C. W. Misner's claims in his article ``Yilmaz Cancels Newton'']
- Edward D. Fackerell, [Remarks on the Yilmaz and Alley papers]; in this preprint Fackerell criticizes several claims by Yilmaz concerning gtr
- Carroll O. Alley and Huseyin Yilmaz, [Response to Fackerell's Article]
- See section 20.4 for nonlocal nature of gravitational field energy, and all of chapter 20 for relation between integration, Bianchi identities, and 'conservation laws' in curved spacetimes.
From Wikipedia, the Free Encyclopedia. Original article here. Support Wikipedia by contributing or donating.
All text is available under the terms of the GNU Free Documentation License See Wikipedia Copyrights for details.